We are committed to continuously improving access to our goods and services by individuals with disabilities. This website is currently being updated to enhance the usability and experience for persons with disabilities. If you are unable to use any aspect of this website because of a disability, please call 603.890.4004 for Salem or 978.358.8576 for Newburyport and we will provide you with prompt personalized assistance.

Artisan Dentistry's Blog

Which Toothpaste Can You Trust? A Dentist’s Guide

Mar 18th, 2026
choose the right toothpaste

With what feels like a million different toothpastes lining store shelves, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. From whitening promises to “natural” labels and premium pricing, how do you know which toothpaste is actually worth it?

Here’s what to look for when selecting a toothpaste you can trust.

Toothpaste Credibility: Look for the ADA Seal

Flashy marketing claims don’t always tell the whole story. The first thing to check when choosing a toothpaste is whether it has the American Dental Association (ADA) Seal of Acceptance.

The ADA seal means the product has been independently tested for safety and effectiveness. If a toothpaste carries this seal, you can feel confident it meets professional standards for oral health.

The Truth About Whitening Toothpastes

Many people hope for a noticeably whiter smile when using whitening toothpaste. However, it’s important to understand what these products can — and cannot — do.

Whitening toothpastes can:

  • Remove surface stains
  • Help maintain brightness after professional whitening

Whitening toothpastes cannot:

  • Change the natural color of your teeth
  • Lighten deep internal stains

If you’re looking for dramatic whitening results, professional treatments are typically more effective.

Does It Contain Fluoride?

The most important ingredient in toothpaste is fluoride.

Fluoride helps:

  • Strengthen enamel
  • Prevent tooth decay
  • Fight plaque buildup

For most patients, a fluoride toothpaste with the ADA seal is the safest and most effective choice for daily use.

Is Expensive Always Better?

Interestingly, higher price doesn’t always mean higher quality.

A study reviewing popular toothpastes found that despite major price differences, most performed similarly in cleaning effectiveness. In many cases, a reliable toothpaste costs under $10 — and value packs can save even more.

When to Ask Your Dentist

Some patients may need specialized toothpaste. For example:

  • People with sensitive teeth
  • Those with gum disease
  • Patients prone to cavities
  • Individuals with dry mouth

Your dentist understands your specific oral health needs and can recommend the best option for you.

Not Sure Which Toothpaste Is Right for You?

At Artisan Dentistry, we believe that great oral health starts with the right daily habits — including choosing the right toothpaste. During your next visit, our team can recommend products tailored to your specific needs, whether you’re managing sensitivity, preventing cavities, or looking to brighten your smile.

Schedule your next cleaning and exam today and let us help you protect your smile with expert, personalized care.

Warranty

Our 5 Year Warranty

Anyone can train to be a technician, but few have the talent to become an artist. That’s why Dr. Mathew is able to guarantee his cosmetic dentistry work for a full 5 years. If anything goes wrong with the work, Dr. Mathew will fix it free of charge, as long as you continue with your regular 6 month preventative care cleaning and check up for the duration of the warranty.

Treatment Room

Individualized
Treatment Rooms

Our individualized treatment rooms and operatories provide patients with maximum privacy and comfort. The treatment rooms were built specifically with your comfort in mind.

Schedule Appointment (Paginated)

  • Fill out the form below.
Choose Location

Salem, NH

Call Now

Newburyport, MA

Call Now

Here at Paul Mathew, D.D.S. we work diligently to protect our patients' privacy. Requesting an appointment via our Internet portal is considered part of what the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) has identified as electronically protected healthcare information or ePHI. Unfortunately, despite our best efforts, there are people or entities that may attempt to intercept the data you transmit to us. By checking the "I agree" box, and electronically making an appointment request, you acknowledge that you are making an appointment over the internet and that Paul Mathew, D.D.S. will keep this information confidential but cannot guarantee that others, outside of our practice, may illegally intercept this communication. By accepting these terms and conditions and sending this request via our Internet portal, you accept the inherent risk(s) associated with making this request for an appointment. If you do not accept the terms and conditions, you are always welcome to contact our office via telephone to schedule your appointment.

X

Here at Paul Mathew, D.D.S. we work diligently to protect our patients' privacy. Requesting an appointment via our Internet portal is considered part of what the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) has identified as electronically protected healthcare information or ePHI. Unfortunately, despite our best efforts, there are people or entities that may attempt to intercept the data you transmit to us. By checking the "I agree" box, and electronically making an appointment request, you acknowledge that you are making an appointment over the internet and that Paul Mathew, D.D.S. will keep this information confidential but cannot guarantee that others, outside of our practice, may illegally intercept this communication. By accepting these terms and conditions and sending this request via our Internet portal, you accept the inherent risk(s) associated with making this request for an appointment. If you do not accept the terms and conditions, you are always welcome to contact our office via telephone to schedule your appointment.

X

The information presented here is not intended or implied to be medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. It should be used for informational purposes only.